MAINTAINING POSITIVE
NEIGHBOR RELATIONS
DURING CONSTRUCTION
No matter where you live, even if outside of the city, if you are doing any kind of renovation or construction project it is highly recommended that you take proactive steps to maintain good relationships with your neighbors.
Any kind of construction or renovation project, regardless of scale, will create some level of noise, mess, and disruption. In a multi-unit building, debris often must be removed via the common areas (hallways and elevators), and many projects will involve an interruption in water or electrical service. Some work can cause stress on the building’s mechanical systems and, if not handled properly, can cause damage to the building’s systems or to other apartments or common areas. If your neighbor is doing a renovation, it is highly likely that you will be exposed to these conditions at least peripherally.
No one who lives in a co-op is happy to hear that their next door (or worse, upstairs) neighbor is planning a major renovation project. Here are some important tips to keep in mind for maintaining a positive relationship with your neighbors:
WHAT YOU CAN DO
First of all, read and understand the building’s alteration agreement and the attached set of rules related to renovating. Remember, you signed this agreement and if you or your Contractor violate these rules, you can be held responsible legally and financially. At the very least, your neighbors will have good reason to hold a grudge against you for years to come. Just read the thing, understand the rules and follow them as best you can.
Second, make sure your Contractor does the same. You should verify this even if you trust your Contractor. You don’t have to be aggressive, just double-check. Perhaps mention if there have been recent incidents or complaints in the building in order to emphasize that the rules need to be taken seriously.
You should notify your neighbors whenever you are going to be doing work in your apartment. Usually we recommend that you notify adjoining neighbors including the upstairs and downstairs and across the hall. Anyone that might be feeling the vibration if you bang on one of your walls should be notified. You should do this in writing but hand-deliver the note if possible. Include the renovation schedule and your contact information in case any issues need to be addressed.
It’s also a good idea, and sometimes required, to post a similar letter in the elevator or building lobby. Additionally, and especially for a major project, it’s a great idea to bring a bottle of wine or a gift basket as an apology in advance to the neighbors that will be most directly affected. This might be going over the top for a smaller project, but is definitely recommended for anything lasting more than 6-8 weeks. Check in with your neighbors upon project completion and for long-term projects check in periodically.
WHAT YOUR CONTRACTOR CAN DO
Possibly the most important thing for your Contractor to do is to be clean and respectful when using the common areas. These include hallways, vestibules, lobbies, elevators, outdoor and roof spaces. On our own jobs we will often go above and beyond the building’s rules, especially if the building does not have a strong alteration agreement. Leaving dust or debris in the hallways is probably the most common cause of complaints in co-op renovations.
Some multi-unit residential buildings have commercial storefront spaces at street-level, private medical practices within individual apartments, or other commercial spaces that operate within the building. If any of these spaces are adjacent your renovation, engage with the business owners directly and find out if they have any specific needs. Remember that they are operating a business and that their livelihood and reputation depends on their ability to continue doing so. There’s also a greater legal risk in causing disruption to a business where real money can be lost.
Contractors should be operating completely independent of the building’s services and systems. Renovation debris should not go out with the building’s trash, it should be carted away by the Contractor or one of their Subcontractors. Doormen should not be accepting deliveries for the Contractor, and building staff should not be cleaning up after them or performing repairs related to the renovation.
If a building does not have a dedicated service access to the apartment, such as a service elevator or stairwell with a door that opens directly into the apartment, the common hallways will have to be used for access. Hallways and common areas should only be used for access and for delivering equipment and materials, they should never be used as work areas. With few exceptions, the hallway floor should be protected every day and the protection should be removed at the end of each work day so that the residents can have a sense of normalcy when they return home in the evenings. The best and most common floor protection is ¼” hardboard, commonly referred to as Masonite in the trades. Many buildings will even call out how they want the floors to be protected and with what product in their alteration agreements.
Another important item is to protect the elevator, assuming there is one and if there is no service elevator. This is primarily the duty of the building’s superintendent or staff, but your Contractor needs to coordinate closely with them. Generally, the elevator will have a set of wall-covering pads which are made to fit and hang on little metal pegs on the elevator walls. The building’s staff is responsible for storing and maintaining these pads and for installing them at the beginning of each work day and removing them at the end. The Contractor will usually cut a piece of Masonite to fit the elevator floor and install it with the rest of the hallway floor covering. If the Contractor scratches the elevator walls or floor not only will this be nearly impossible to touch-up, but everyone in the building will see it and be annoyed, not just the neighbors on your floor.
Workers should generally be as low-impact as possible in the common areas, there should not be any loitering, hanging-out, or loud conversation. Contractors should coordinate deliveries with building staff so that inconvenience can be as minimal as possible. Unfortunately, this is not always possible (Your new fridge will be arriving sometime between 7AM and 9PM on Tuesday, sound familiar?). Workers should also make sure that their feet are clean when they leave the work area so that dust is not being tracked everywhere. The little things make a difference.
In the apartment, a dust barrier (plastic sheet) should be installed on one side of the apartment entry door. Contractors will always make noise, this cannot be avoided, but radios and loud-music can be and this will also usually be called out in the building’s rules. Demolition work should be done in one shot, and as quickly as possible rather than spread out over weeks. This is usually the noisiest and dustiest work and I would strongly recommend to every Contractor that you just get it over with. Neighbors will be annoyed by the noise and vibration, but they will eventually forget. Don’t remind them by dragging out the demolition process by doing it in phases. This is also one of many reasons it is best to bundle all your projects into one large renovation rather than becoming the resident that is “always doing work in their apartment”.
Another special circumstance that may occur, especially in the summer in NYC, is multiple projects in a building happening at once. Sometimes, the building may be doing capital improvements to common areas, the roof, or the façade. If this is the case it’s even more important for the Contractor to be diligent about following rules, to document their activities as much as possible, and to segregate their work from other Contractors as much as possible.
SUMMARY OF GENERAL POINTS
• When selecting a Contractor, consider one that understands what it is like to work/live in a co-op or condo building.
• Respect the building’s rules and common areas. Your Contractor should be treating the neighbors as clients. Make sure your Contractor maintains a good relationship with building staff and respects their particular needs.
• Be proactive, notify them in advance. Apologize in advance.
• Put yourself in your neighbor’s position, be empathetic. It’s not fun for anyone.
• Bring gifts
• Most likely your Contractor will be on site more than you will be, when you check in with them, ask about the neighbors, find out if they have had any interaction, negative or positive. Obviously, when you meet with your Contractor you will have all kinds of issues to address related to the project, taking the time to ask about the neighbors will show them that it is important to you.
• Set up lines of communication with your neighbors.
• Remind everybody that you are improving the property and that this benefits all of the shareholders.
• Establish hours that work with your neighbors. Follow the building’s guidelines but also tell your neighbors when lunches and breaks will be and ask if they need any specific times to be “quiet times” (within reason).
• Point out things that you may be doing which will benefit the relationship in the long run, such as soundproofing and waterproofing. Don’t point these things out aggressively as if you expect something in return, but mention them so that they are noticed and appreciated.
• If you live in a multi-unit building. Don’t plan to renovate every year, or every two years. Save up and do a big project that will cover everything on your to-do list. Not only will this probably save you money, because the work will be more cost-efficient, you won’t be that shareholder that’s “always doing work in his/her apartment”.
MUST-DO CHECKLIST:
• Notify all neighbors in adjacent apartments, upstairs and downstairs and across the hall. Include some explanation of the scope and duration of work, your contact information, and an apology in advance for any inconvenience. This should be done in writing but if you can hand-deliver the letter this would be a good idea.
• Make sure your Contractor also checks in with neighbors to see if they have any needs that are not already addressed in the buildings by-laws (i.e. baby’s nap time, zoom meetings if a shareholder is working remotely).
• Read and follow the building’s rules and guidelines for renovations and make sure your Contractor does the same. In some instances, your building’s list may be thin, see our post on alteration agreements and renovation guidelines.
• Check in with your neighbors upon project completion and for long-term projects check in periodically.
CONCLUSION
The purpose of planning a project thoroughly is to save money, save time, better understand the needs of the client, and prevent conflict. Every problem has a root cause. In the home renovation business, the root cause of most problems is poor planning. Homeowners are often incentivized or even encouraged to move fast, get started on the work, and work through the problems as they come. The renovation business, especially in New York City, has gotten too complex for this approach to work effectively. Pre-Construction costs money because it saves money. Many or our clients will spend 20 or 30% of the purchase price of their apartment on a renovation, more than a car, sometimes more than a second home outside of the city might cost. This kind of investment should be made thoughtfully, carefully, and with the help and advice of experienced construction professionals.
IMPORTANCE OF
PRE-CONSTRUCTION
What is it, why is it important, and why itcosts money, etc.
MANAGING
DECISION FATIGUE
8 steps to manage a nearly universal problem faced by homeowners enduring a major renovation.